Nov. 1, 2026 - 1 John 3:1-3 - All Saints' Day
A couple of weeks ago I had someone ask me if Jesus had an siblings. Itās a fairly innocuous question and, for most people, it doesnāt really matter one way or the other. Still, we had a brief discussion about how the scene in Mark 3, where Jesus is in a house surrounded by a crowd and someone says his mother and brothers are outside seeking him. Certain groups who have a particular teaching theyāre trying to protect will say that the Hebrew word for brothers could refer to nephews or cousins. St. Paul also mentions a man named James and says heās Jesusā brother. Itās generally believed that this James is the author of the epistle of James. Those same people will point out that the name āJesusā wasnāt all that uncommon and that it was perfectly reasonable for there to be another prominent Jesus who had a brother named James. There are more direct references as well, so thereās not much to support the argument against it unless youāre pushing a particular agenda.
Some of those who argue against Jesus having brothers are trying to hold up the idea that Mary remained a virgin throughout her life. The Bible never says anything of the sort. It implies quite the opposite. We have no reason to believe anything else in Maryās life was unusual outside of Jesus. The much more likely answer is that Jesus did have siblings, at least a few brothers. Matthewās Gospel also tells us pretty plainly that Jesus not only had brothers, but sisters as well.
Still, the idea of Jesus having siblings is an interesting one to consider. What would life be like in that household? You start with Mary and Joseph. With the close knit extended families that were the norm in those days, itās a certainty that Mary and Joseph got plenty of parenting advice from their own parents, aunts, and uncles. That would have been standard, and yet, much of that advice would have been completely meaningless when it came to Jesus. Different ways to get your kid to eat his vegetables? Not a problem. How to get your kid to help do chores? Also not a problem. What to do when your kid is lying? Definitely donāt need that. Home remedies for when your kid is sick? Given that later on Jesus will be healing other people, itās not certain but at least possible he never even got sick. On and on it goes. A lot of parenting is about discipline and encouraging virtue, teaching basic skills and how to deal with the world. Some of that would still apply to Jesus in his humanity, but anything that dealt with sin would be completely unnecessary. Mary and Joseph probably didnāt really know how good they had it until they had baby number 2.
So now put yourself on the other side. What is it like being Jesusā little brother or sister? When mom looks around to see who stole from the cookie jar, you canāt point at Jesus. When you secretly feed your unwanted vegetables to the dog, you canāt say, āJesus told me to do it.ā If youāre one of those families that keeps a chart of all of the various chores that need doing, Jesus will have a check mark next to every chore, every day. Bed made? Check. Teeth brushed? Check. Bath? Check. Clothes folded? Check. Every, single, day.
If I were one of Jesusā younger brothers, Iād probably end up thinking along the same lines as Josephās brothers did so long ago. āHeās making us look bad. Weāve got to get rid of him or it will just be like this forever.ā Thankfully, thereās no indication Jesusā brothers tried to sell him into slavery, but they didnāt count themselves among his followers, not until much later. Living with Jesus, watching him always do the right thing, watching him avoid all of the punishments you got, not because he was sneaky or dishonest, but because he genuinely never did anything bad, it would grate on you and probably lead to a certain amount of jealousy.
It would be nice to say that having an older brother like that would be a great motivator to do better. The reality is that laziness and complacency are pretty well baked into human nature. Knowing I could be better and actually wanting to be better are two different things. I could be better, but Iād rather be good enough just like I am. Thereās the old wilderness survival axiom that says, āYou donāt need to outrun the bear. You just need to outrun the guy next to you.ā Thatās just as true in situations like this. I donāt really need to be perfect. I just need to be better than the people around me. If I get rid of Jesus, suddenly Iām in the #1 spot, at least according to my own grading system. Thatās the only one that matters anyway.
That āJesus problemā hasnāt really gone away. As St. John says, we are Godās children. Heās still the perfect older brother. Thereās the situation every teacher runs into at some point. You have a naughty kid in class and you have to confront the parents about his behavior and the response is, āMy little Kevin would never do that. Youāre mistaken.ā Except in Jesusā case thatās actually true. Jesus never does the bad thing. Not even once. You, on the other hand, donāt have a stellar track record. Sometimes youāre probably doing well to even hit 50% and thatās probably generous.
So the easy answer is to just get rid of Jesus. After all, trying to do enough, to better yourself enough to even be on the same playing field as him would be basically impossible. Not to mention, Iāve seen the people who firmly believe they have to work their way to the top, who have to prove their goodness, their righteousness, who have to prove theyāre at least in shouting distance of Jesus. Theyāre scared, scared they arenāt going to make it, scared of the consequences of failure. No, thatās a miserable existence too. Rather than trying to measure up to Jesus, Iāll just be the one others are measured against. Then no one will be wondering why I donāt try and make myself better. Theyāll be too busy wondering why everyone else isnāt as good as I am.
On All Saintsā Day, we take time to consider all of the saints in our lives, and most especially those who have gone before us. Iāve been to many funerals in my day. Most of the time Iām the one presiding over the service, but Iāve been to a number of others. The ones conducted by non-Lutherans tend to have a common theme. The homily usually revolves around the deceasedās life. We who are there attending are treated to a detailed account of how good this person was and what noble and commendable things he or she had done. Often weāre also regaled with an account of the life theyāre probably leading now. āHeās up there now, riding his horses, just like he always loved to do.ā āSheās baking her heart out now. You can bet all of heaven smells like chocolate cake right now.ā In each case, the underlying message is, āHe was a great guy and now heās getting to live his best life.ā āShe was always caring and now everyone else gets to see how caring she is too.ā
St. John calls us āchildren of God,ā and so I say to you, brothers and sisters in Christ, that is not the Gospel. That is not the good news. That message says, āYou were good enough before and now you get to be good enough forever.ā If Iām good enough forever, then that means Iām still getting into trouble. Iām still making a mess of things. Iām still shaking my fist at Jesus because he will always and forever be making me look bad. Not because he sabotages me. Not because he picks on me. Itās just because heās always around and heās always, always, perfect, and Iām...not, and deep down I hate him for being a reminder that Iām not really as good as I know I should be.
We donāt celebrate those who have gone before us and give thanks that they were āgood enough.ā Jesus doesnāt come to earth to rub our noses in our own failure. He doesnāt wander around like a power mad older brother, checking to make sure weāre doing everything our parents tell us to do and tattling on us when we donāt. He knows, no matter how hard we try, even in those times when weāre really, really trying, weāll never be like him. We donāt even get close. Even without the danger of hell, eternity would still mean being stuck in our earthly lives, subject to grief and sadness, subject to pain and depression, subject to a hopeless and eternal future. Jesus, our brother, truly loves us in a way the world doesnāt know or understand. He knows we canāt make ourselves better. He knows weāll never be free of the sadness or death because weāre always heaping it upon ourselves.
Jesus comes here to make us better. Not as a motivational speaker, pushing us into a self-help scheme that requires imperfect people to try and make themselves perfect. He doesnāt come as a slave driver, flogging us to work day in and day out in an effort to push us to perfection. Neither of those would work and so he doesnāt bother with either method, nor does he just abandon us in frustration. Jesus comes to make us perfect in the only way we can be made perfect, by living a perfect life and then giving that perfect life to us.
In a world and a society that wants everyone to be ok with everyone else just the way they are, God wants something different. He isnāt ok with us as we are and doesnāt want us to be ok with ourselves. He sees the effects of sin and what it does in our lives. He sees the misery it causes and the sadness that we can never escape from. This isnāt normal and just being āgood enoughā means never being rid of these things. It means living with them forever.
The good news that comes to you is that this doesnāt have to be your end. This doesnāt have to be your future. When we talk about salvation here, we talk about it in a number of different ways. Thereās forgiveness, as God wipes our sins away. There is redemption, as God pays our debt of sin. Here there is eternal life, perfect life. The resurrection we confess and that we look forward to is not an eternity thatās much the same as what we have now, maybe an eternity reunited with friends and family who have gone before us. It is a resurrection in the life of Christ. It is perfect life. Our life doesnāt go on forever because God just says so. It goes on forever because we are made perfect. As perfect people, death no longer threatens us. Sadness never enters the picture. Relationships are never broken. In a world full of perfect people, nothing ever goes bad because every bad thing is ultimately the result of sin.
On All Saintsā Day, we give thanks to God for sending those saints to be a part of our lives. We give thanks that they shared the good news with us and shared His love with us in whatever ways they were able. There are aspects of each of the saints that are worth emulating to one degree or another. More than that, we give thanks to God for what he has done for them. We give thanks that Jesus never thought of them as āgood enough.ā He wanted what was best for them. He wanted perfection, and so he came to die and rise again that they may have that they may have it. So that we may have it.