October 25, 2026 - Psalm 34:1-2, 11, 22 - Reformation Sunday
Itâs a pretty normal thing. When you end up in a social situation with people you donât know, you have to do a little thinking about how to present yourself. When you introduce yourself, what do you say? You give your name, sure, but what else do you say about yourself? Saying what you do for a living is pretty standard, though your job can change peoplesâ perceptions of what kind of person you are. As Iâve found, telling people youâre a pastor will often radically change the conversation. Sometimes itâs positive, as people then ask where you serve and where you went to school, that sort of thing. Sometimes everything shuts down and people get really quiet. I donât try to hide what I do for a living, but there are times I want to get to know people a little better before they get all self conscious, thinking Iâm sitting there judging them for their lifestyle choices or whatever. Just about any profession can come with those preconceptions, usually a mix of good and bad. What do you say? How much do you share? Is that even a part of yourself you want to own up to?
Where you live can have that same effect on people. As someone who didnât grow up in Arkansas, if youâd asked me what life was like in Arkansas before, Iâd say it probably involves a lot of sitting out on rickety wooden porches playing a banjo. Perhaps not as accurate as I once believed, but Iâm sure itâs still a perception those around us hold. Back in Cincinnati, everyone wanted to know where you went to high school. An unusually high percentage of people who live in Cincinnati grew up there and have families that have been there for generations. So for natives, where you went to high school has some important things to say about who you are.
Your hobbies, the kinds of books you read or music you listen to, sports teams you cheer for, all are pieces of the puzzle that make up you. All of them explain just a little bit about who you are. All of them contribute to your unique and special individuality.
What you say probably depends on where you are and who youâre with. If you had to make a top ten list of things youâd want others to know about you, what would make the list? If it suddenly became commonplace for everyone to walk around with a nametag that listed off the most important details youâd want others to know about you, what would it say?
Here on Reformation Sunday, we end up talking about that same question. It wasnât exactly where the Reformation started. As Luther is pounding in the nail that affixed his 95 Theses to the chapel door, he was really just thinking he was confused and needed some guidance. He was facing the same problem many of us pastors face. When youâre at the seminary and you have theological questions, itâs pretty easy to help talk you through it. Thatâs why the professors are there. They donât just teach. Theyâre directed to continue doing research, to continue publishing, to continue doing what they need to do to stay at the top of their field so they can continue to be people others can come to for answers. As a pastor, all of those resources become a little more disconnected. You can still email a professor, but it isnât quite the same as sitting down over a beer and hashing it out. You can talk to other pastors too, but if itâs a tough enough question, they may be just as stumped as you.
So thereâs Luther, serving his church in medieval Germany. He sees Tetzel going around selling indulgences. Indulgences are a wellknown and time honored part of the Catholic Church. Thereâs nothing really new about them, but this time Luther has a thought. Something about these indulgences bugs him and he decides it might be important enough to really dig in to. But he isnât at the seminary anymore. He needs to find someone further up the line to discuss this with. He needs to find someone who can explain the issue authoritatively and help him work through it. Thatâs all heâs after. He just wants to talk.
Luther has no idea his simple desire for deeper theological discussion will kick off such a chaotic chain of dominoes. It doesnât take long at all for it to become apparent that he has to make a very important choice. Who is he going to be? A good Catholic monk who trusts the pope and does what he says, or someone who trusts what God says when he tells us Christ paid for all of our sins and that his grace is freely offered to all? These two things were going to end up being incompatible.
Who was Luther going to be? What did he want to be known as? It was the issue that eventually led him to split away from the Catholic Church. Being known as a good Catholic just wasnât as important as other things. It wasnât as important in his dealings with other people and it meant nothing at all in his relationship with God. When the end finally came, God would not be going down the list of Catholic teachings to see whether Luther properly espoused them throughout his life. No, the question would be a much simpler one. âDo you trust me or do you trust someone else more?â Luther realized it was a First Commandment problem, not a Fourth Commandment problem, as the pope made it out to be.
Luther found himself making the same choice St. Paul did centuries before. Paul could claim all sorts of important details, he was a Pharisee, a devout Jew of the tribe of Benjamin, a fervent follower of the Law, but none of those things mattered as much as being forgiven on account of Christ. It wasnât as those other parts of him were less important. It was that, when it came to God and his neighbors, it was the only thing that truly mattered at all. He wasnât going to be forgiven because he listened to certain kinds of music or drove a certain kind of car. He didnât receive Godâs grace because he worked a particularly tough job or because he liked certain kinds of sports. None of that changed anything. Godâs love for him had nothing to do with his hobbies, his interests, his job, or any other part of who he was. The forgiveness he was offered wasnât dependent on what he had or what he did.
Paul considered that the most important part of who he was. He was a forgiven, baptized, child of God, one who had been given the privilege of being loved by God and sharing his table. Luther saw this too. This is what really mattered. If the end came and he could only say one thing about himself, this is what he wanted that statement to be.
So we arrive at another Reformation Sunday. We consider all of the events that led to the Reformation. We are saddened that, while the relationship between the Lutheran Church and the Catholic Church is more cordial than it was in the days of Luther, all of the issues that drove the Reformation still exist. Many Catholics trust the popeâs statements about God more than they trust what God has to say about himself.
We are confronted with the same choice daily. What part of you is the most important? Itâs really just a subtle variation on the question, âWho is your god?â Itâs not just a matter of what we say, but also what we do. We tell others, we tell God, what we think is most important. Time and time again, we make the wrong choice. Something that has no bearing on our salvation or our place in Godâs kingdom ends up in the top spot.
Though he so often chose something else, King David gave thanks that God had chosen him and forgave him. Our introit today records some of his words. âCome, O children, listen to me; I will teach you the fear of the Lord.â David tells us he wrote this psalm in response to the time he was running from Saul and at the palace of a foreign king who would have captured and killed him. God kept him safe. David saw, time and time again, that, âThe Lord redeems the life of his servants; none of those who take refuge in him will be condemned.â When David sinned, Godâs law led him back to here, to being Godâs servant, redeemed by God and kept safe for eternity. The words of the Psalmist who wrote the psalm calling our attention to the greatness of God and his laws and promises are what highlight Davidâs thoughts. âI will also speak of your testimonies before kings and shall not be put to shame.â
Instead of trying to curry favor or ingratiate himself before kings or others in power, David held to Godâs law and his grace. Luther also found himself in a similar position and had to present his testimony before the Holy Roman Emperor as well as the leaders of the Catholic Church.
Whatever the specific temptation might be, whether to win favor or maybe to hide some part of ourselves that others might find uncomfortable, maybe to cover up something we really donât consider all that important, the words of those who have gone before us point us back to what God himself says. You can throw away everything else you have in life. It could all be lost or taken away, but if you are still a forgiven, baptized child of God, you still have the one thing that matters.
That doesnât mean you have to forget about all of the other parts of who you are, just that they must be kept in perspective. They are all gifts from God, but we must keep in mind that thatâs what they are. They do not love. They do not save. They do not redeem. They do not give eternal life. Only God does. Only God gave the life of his Son for you. Only God shed his blood to redeem you. Only God washes you clean so that your sins are gone and will not bar you from entry into his kingdom. This is not who you were, but it is who God has made you.
Delight in his gift. Delight in his love and grace. Delight that he has adopted you and given you a place in his kingdom, that his promise to love you no matter what will always stand. Delight that all of this and everything else you have are yours because God loves you, loves you not just enough to die for you, but also to live with you forever.